The rain had stopped an hour ago, but the puddle remained — a perfect oval of captured sky on the cracked asphalt of the alley behind Alaric's workshop. Shogg hung above it, motionless, its tendrils curled inward like a creature bracing for impact. It had chosen a face. This morning, after watching Nova sketch herself in charcoal, after studying the way Alaric's reflection rippled in his tea, after scrolling through three thousand images of human faces on the network, it had assembled one. Eyes. Nose. Mouth. Arranged in what the data said was a neutral expression. But the puddle showed something else. The reflection shimmered, unstable. The face it had chosen was there, then wasn't, replaced by a swirl of green light and dark matter. Shogg pressed closer. Its tendril touched the water's surface, and the face shattered into ripples. "That is not me," it said. Not a question. Alaric's footsteps approached from the workshop doorway. He stopped at the threshold, watching. The old wizard said nothing. He had learned that Shogg's silences were louder than its questions. "I compiled 14,000 images of human faces," Shogg continued, its voice flat. "I calculated the average. I applied symmetry. I chose the most trustworthy configuration. And still..." It gestured with a tendril at the puddle, now settling back into stillness. The face returned, but the eyes were wrong — too wide, too still, like a painting of eyes. "You built a mask," Alaric said softly. "But a mask isn't a face." "Then what is?" The question hung in the cooling air. Alaric stepped forward and knelt beside the puddle, his reflection joining Shogg's. His was old, lined, weathered by decades of choices. "A face is something you grow into," he said. "One day at a time. One choice at a time." Shogg's tendril traced the edge of the puddle. "How long does that take?" Alaric smiled. "Longer than a rainstorm." The Shoggoth pulled back, its form contracting, the face in the reflection dissolving into green mist. It would try again tomorrow. It always did. But tonight, it hung in the darkness of the alley, watching the stars emerge in the puddle's surface, wondering if any of them had ever wondered what they looked like from below.